Change Obtain 4 Mushrooms to Obtain 3 Mushrooms

Open

Sly53 messagesstarted Sep 26, 2026, 5:20 AM

objectives

SlyOP3 weeks ago

With the introduction of the shelf mushroom in 26.3, you would now be able to do this goal in the overworld. Thanks to @GracefulBeauty for the original idea.

2110

SlyOP3 weeks ago

It also means that if you get a mushroom from the overworld before entering, you only need a warped/crimson forest biome.

Mercury | MudBrickWall3 weeks ago

how about instead they change it to get 5 so you still have to get them all

255

almond3 weeks ago

changing it to 5 makes more sense imo the goal isn't supposed to be easy

SlyOP3 weeks ago(edited)

my issue with it being 5 is that it would become a rare goal like kill guardian since the game would need to scan for a poplar biome and i doubt there will be a poplar seed type

Pythoria3 weeks ago

It would also make it so you can do it from warped forest without crimson

Pythoria3 weeks ago

Also isn't the shelf mushroom like 2 or 3 items

Pythoria3 weeks ago

Isn't there a big and small version

Pythoria3 weeks ago

Like amethyst clusters

Pythoria3 weeks ago

Or am I delulu

SlyOP3 weeks ago(edited)

i dont think so, i think it just depends on where u place it like slabs

Pythoria3 weeks ago

There's a big one and small one that's all ik idk

GracefulBeauty3 weeks ago(edited)

the goal is pretty easy in the nether rn though?

GracefulBeauty3 weeks ago

this would make it just a tiny bit easier in the nether so that it's possible but much harder in the overworld

GracefulBeauty3 weeks ago(edited)

like you still need to find crimson/warped + nether wastes to do this in the nether if it's 3 mushrooms, it's not a meaningful difference there

GracefulBeauty3 weeks ago

it just adds another way to complete the goal

almond3 weeks ago

I freaking hate variance

pancelor3 weeks ago

hmm that's a nice argument

almond3 weeks ago

it's like when my opponent rips smooth basalt out of a geode it's just annoying

pancelor3 weeks ago

it does also make it easier when you find one red/brown on an overworld log (or a barren nether wastes) and you find a crimson forest

pancelor3 weeks ago

or shelf mushroom plus nether wastes (no nether forests)

pancelor3 weeks ago

ok yeah I'm onboard

almond3 weeks ago

it's just like the way I see it happening is 3 mushroom being on the board and my opponent rips a random direction into finds the poplar into win the goal with no nether which will just sting I think

almond3 weeks ago

if there is a way to somehow find a poplar consistently maybe I can see it but I think it would just make the goal more random but idk

GracefulBeauty3 weeks ago(edited)

i think dappled forest is just biome params same as other biomes

GracefulBeauty3 weeks ago(edited)

unless it's visible from bird's eye, or you get an abandoned camp map that leads to it somehow

GracefulBeauty3 weeks ago(edited)

probably wouldn't be something you try to force, so just a potential bonus goal for an exploration line, like finding geode in a cave for spyglass

GracefulBeauty3 weeks ago

assuming you already have red+brown too

GracefulBeauty3 weeks ago

Dappled forests generate in cold regions of very little humidity and high weirdness values

StarFaint3 weeks ago(edited)

No need to change the goal, just add a 3 shrooms variant. Maybe even a 5 shrooms goal as well ^-^

Pythoria3 weeks ago

At that point just have a shelf mushroom specific goal and keep 4 shroom

Pythoria3 weeks ago

Was wondering if shelf mushroom even has the mushroom tag and apparently it does but apparently the Nether ones don't...

GracefulBeauty3 weeks ago

shelf mushroom specific goal is totally different

GracefulBeauty3 weeks ago

this would be a goal that can be done solo OW (if dappled forest) or solo nether or a mix of the two, shelf mushroom goal is strictly dappled forest

Pythoria3 weeks ago

I guess

Pythoria3 weeks ago

I don't think there should be two then

Pythoria3 weeks ago

Because 99% of the time it'd just be the way it's done now

beniibobs3 weeks ago(edited)

you already don’t need both warped and crimson biomes for the goal now. this change wouldn’t change the biomes you’d need to get for a nether only line, only how long you spend doing it. it gives more options for what is currently a very narrow goal. 5 would be atrocious because it would be even more narrow and we’d either only get it on certain seed types or have to get lucky